Not-so-high hopes


Make text smaller Make text larger


Sutton Place community rallies for a “race against time”


Photos



  • A rendering of a Sutton Place tower proposed in 2015 that would have been among the tallest in Manhattan.




  • How the Sutton Place tower would have stacked up, in an image distributed by the developer.




Residents of Sutton Place, the neighborhood between First Avenue and the East River from 53rd to 59th Streets, are pinning their hopes on Marisa Lago, the incoming director of the Department of City Planning. When Lago’s tenure begins on March 1, her desk could be piled high with objections from the community to the proposed construction of an 850-foot luxury residential tower at 430 East 58th Street.

“I think there’s nothing better than getting a shitload of letters before you even start,” Borough President Gale Brewer told attendees of a town hall on Friday, Feb. 10, encouraging them to raise their voices. “It is necessary to make sure the advocacy is there.” Approximately 80 people gathered in the Skytop Lounge of the Plaza 400 to hear updates on the tower’s progress, sign a petition and donate to the cost of opposing it.

After plans for the tower were announced in 2015, neighbors sprang into action to form the East River Fifties Alliance (ERFA). The group hired planners and consultants to help develop a zoning text amendment that would limit building heights to 260 feet, as well as requesting more affordable housing, which the Alliance filed to the Department of City Planning this past December. “ERFA is proposing a contextual district that would prevent supertowers through height limits, and would provide greater incentives for affordable housing, and design controls for wide buildings,” the application reads. It cited, as inspiration for the zoning text amendment, Mayor Bill de Blasio’s “mandate to make all of New York City a diverse and balanced community.” The Department of City Planning has yet to certify the group’s application as complete so that it may begin undergoing the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure.

Meanwhile, the Sutton Place tower has been beset by issues — both financial and social — since the beginning, and was sold to Gamma Real Estate at a foreclosure auction this past December. In January, the plans to move forward with construction were rejected by the Department of Buildings as incomplete, though a spokesperson for the agency told DNAinfo at the time that this was not unusual for new building permits.

With both the rezoning application and the Sutton place plans currently stalled, it is now a question of what will be approved first. “We are all in a race against time,” Lisa Mercurio, the Alliance’s director of communications, said at the town hall. “We believe we’ve filed a complete application, and frankly we can’t understand why this process is taking so long. If the foundation is poured for [the tower] before the zoning law can be amended, it’s game over.”

Brewer suggested that the city planning commission’s concern was setting a precedent, which she called “a ridiculous reason” not to approve the community’s application. Zoning tends to be regulated by the city, and the efforts of the East River Fifties neighborhoods to determine its own fate are rare. Brewer was joined at the town hall by State Senator Liz Krueger, Council Member Ben Kallos and Council Member Dan Garodnick, who expressed their unwavering support for the Alliance’s proposed zoning text amendment.

Kallos, who has secured several stop work orders against the construction already underway on the project, assured residents that he would continue fighting the developers at every turn. “We will be there as a community to stop them,” he said. The East River Fifties residents will likely be some of the first New Yorkers to schedule an appointment with Lago when she takes office in March.

Madeleine Thompson can be reached at newsreporter@strausnews.com





Make text smaller Make text larger

Comments



MUST READ NEWS

Image Emerald Empire evicts autos
For the first time since the 19th century, Central Park turns its back on the internal combustion engine, embraces anew its original purpose as an urban refuge
Image MTA unveils bus action plan
Proposal calls for updated route network, expanded traffic enforcement and tech upgrades to speed up boarding and travel times
Image A First Look at Pier 17
The waterfront space, featuring restaurants, ESPN studios and rooftop performance venue, will soon open its doors to the public
Image Remembrance and the Great War
Or how a legendary warrior gave his name to an avenue — and how the East Side pays tribute to pluck, heroism and valor
On the block

east side observer

BY ARLENE KAYATT

What’s missing — When a local business goes out, my thoughts are generally about the loss to the...

VIDEOS



Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Neighborhood Newsletters





MOST READ

Local News
A First Look at Pier 17
  • Apr 23, 2018
Local News
Remembrance and the Great War
  • Apr 17, 2018
City Arts News
Bridging generations through music
  • Apr 23, 2018
Local News
Mastering money
  • Apr 17, 2018
Local News
MTA unveils bus action plan
  • Apr 24, 2018

MOST COMMENTED